Films of faith, hope and love: Tarkovsky and the Silver Age religious philosophers

I have it in mind to write a long essay, or perhaps a short book, with the above title, or something close to it.  I haven’t definitely decided on the structure or plan, but the idea of using the three virtues – faith, hope and love – appeals to me at the moment, with the following films and philosophers:

Stalker – Lev Shestov (Faith)
Rublev – Semyon Frank (Hope)
Mirror – Vasily Rozanov (Love)

By referring to the three “theological” virtues I risk being misunderstood.  Let me be clear.  In my view, Tarkovsky was not a dogmatic Christian, not someone for whom Christianity answered all questions and settled all accounts.  He was greatly interested in the religions of the East.  He read books by spiritual seekers and guides as diverse as Steiner, Gurdjieff and Castaneda.  Therefore, I think it would be wrong, in this context, from among the Silver Age religious philosophers, to choose the Orthodox priests Pavel Florensky and Sergei Bulgakov (notwithstanding the fact that Tarkovsky referred to Florensky in connection with the latter’s writings on iconography).  Russian religious philosophy and Orthodox theology have many points of contact, but their differences must be respected.  Thus, the three virtues are meant to be taken in a wider sense than theologians would countenance, as befits the Silver Age religious philosophical tradition that Tarkovsky credited with forming his worldview.

In terms of a direct influence on Tarkovsky, it is easy to justify the choice of Semyon Frank, but Lev Shestov and Vasily Rozanov would be harder to justify, since I’ve not seen that Tarkovsky referred to the latter men by name.  But I do not think it can, or should, be only a question of direct influence, even in the case of Semyon Frank.  I choose Shestov, Frank and Rozanov, to be paired with Stalker, Rublev and Mirror, respectively, because I believe that each philosopher resonates with each film so as to enhance our appreciation of both sides of each pairing.  Even if it could be demonstrated that Tarkovsky never actually read Shestov or Rozanov, I maintain that bringing these philosophers into close proximity with these particular films works.  Ultimately, this is for the reader to decide, of course, but this is my hope at least.  And if I lack the scholar-pedant’s desire to painstakingly confirm and trace every influence, it is because too often I have seen such exercises grind great men and their works into dust, beyond all hope of reconstitution or even recognition.  Better not to set pen to paper, than to set the children’s teeth on edge.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Andrei Rublev, Frank, Semyon, Mirror, Rozanov, Vasily, Russian religious philosophy, Shestov, Lev, Stalker, Tarkovsky, Andrei. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Films of faith, hope and love: Tarkovsky and the Silver Age religious philosophers

  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Films of faith, hope and love: Tarkovsky and the Silver Age religious philosophers « Extravagant Creation -- Topsy.com

  2. adamsnavel says:

    So did you?

    • No, not yet. Not that it should matter, but it does: you’re the only person who has ever expressed an interest (if you’ll allow me to characterize your question in that way) in the topic. It is now exponentially more likely that I will do it. Thank you.

      • adamsnavel says:

        Go for it. I’m looking around for a topic for my PhD in theology. My interests are aesthetics, eschatology and ethics. I’ve just discovered Tarkovsky and I’m very excited by his films. I need to explore what’s been written already on his work. Can you recommend a place to start?

  3. leJean says:

    Did you write the essay now? I would be very interested!

  4. laorencha says:

    More clamor from the peanut gallery: I, too, would like to read this. Thank you!

  5. elithewalrus says:

    And here I am, too! I’m a PhD in theology, MA in Philosophy, big love for Tarkovskij and interest for Russian philosophy and theology! If you have written something, I would be super interested!

  6. adamsnavel says:

    Maybe we should start a group blog on Tarkovsky and theology?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s